The original: Parfums de Marly Althaïr EDP
Parfums de Marly's 2023 vanilla masculine, and the house's answer to the gourmand boom. Ceylon cinnamon and Guatemalan cardamom over Madagascan bourbon vanilla, landing on praline, tonka and candied almond. Warm, sweet and very loud. Opinion on it is genuinely split: some reviewers call it the best vanilla in the designer space, others call it flat and overpriced for what it is.
| Dupe | Match | Price |
|---|---|---|
| French Avenue Liquid Brun | 91% | $45 |
Althaïr EDP retails around $400.
How we score. Every percentage comes from cross-referencing note pyramids against Fragrantica and brand-official sources, then weighting what people who own both fragrances actually report. We don't publish anything below 85%, and we say when something barely clears.
#1French Avenue Liquid Brun
Shares with the original: Cinnamon, Cardamom, Orange Blossom, Bergamot, Bourbon Vanilla, Elemi, Tonka, Ambroxan, Guaiac Wood, Praline, Musk
Eleven of Althaïr's twelve notes, missing only the candied almond — the closest note match anywhere in our database. The most striking evidence sits on Althaïr's own Fragrantica page, where a reviewer who has worn both argues the expensive one is the lesser fragrance: the notes are almost identical, they say, but Brun is more appealing and lasts longer, and the difference comes down to the raw materials. It is also a fraction of the price. We have no other entry where someone who owns both prefers the clone outright. Two things keep this at 91 rather than higher. That testimony, striking as it is, comes from one named reviewer and a tech blog rather than a side-by-side from a fragrance publication. And the candied almond really is absent, which is part of what gives the original its marzipan edge in the drydown. One disclosure while we are here: one of the two shops linked below, Blue Chateau 25, is run by someone we know personally. We earn nothing from either link, and it is listed because it was the cheaper of the two on the day we checked — but you should know the connection exists.
Sources: Fragrantica reviewer on the Althaïr page (owner of both) · published note breakdown
More from Parfums de Marly
Search anything else
Our full database covers 128 originals and 215 verified dupes. Search it here.